Showing posts with label Pulitzer Prize. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Pulitzer Prize. Show all posts

Arrowsmith by Sinclair Lewis

Tuesday, January 24, 2012

Title: Arrowsmith
Author: Sinclair Lewis
Genre: Classic, award-winner, medical
Published: 1925
Read for: Battle of the Prizes, American Version and Back to the Classics Challenge 2011
Source: Personal copy

Martin Arrowsmith was introduced to medicine at an early age as he worked as an assistant to a small-town doctor. He decides to become a doctor, but while he is in medical school, he falls in love with research. Torn between his need to provide for his family and his love for pure science, Arrowsmith goes through several occupations and circumstances in his life before coming to a place where he can immerse himself in knowledge.

In a previous life I was a neuroscience major, and my hero was Dr. Dawson Hedges, who taught my introductory psychology class and my behavioral neuroscience class. He is hilarious and also happens to know everything. Anyway, he mentioned this book in passing one day in class, I scribbled it down, and when I discovered it won a Pulitzer, I knew it would be a winning choice for me (I've yet to fail with a Pulitzer. I know it will happen sooner or later and my faith in the prize will be dashed to smithereens and I won't know where to turn for a fantastic book. But until then...). I was correct -- Arrowsmith was a perfect read for my medical, science-nerd side, and was written well enough to satisfy my lovely-language-loving side.

I have recently made the acquaintance of the term bildungsroman. I am unsure of the translation (and yes, I know I can google it) but essentially, it is a book about the development of a person. I have also come to realize this is my favorite type of book. Perhaps it is because I am in my twenties and am still trying to figure out my future (sure, I'm married and have gone to college (twice) but there are still many, many uncertain things), but books that slowly unravel a person's mishaps and victories on the path to self-dom tend to reach me more personally than any others. And Arrowsmith definitely goes through many changes. He was so very human and fallible, constantly hurting people accidentally, changing his mind about his occupation (general doctor? public health administrator? lab rat?), and falling in and out of love. I have changed my major extensively and am certainly susceptible to making all variations of dumb mistakes, as I think most people are, so this reverberated with me. At times I would cringe at Arrowsmith's choices, and at times I didn't like him as a character. However, I saw in him myself and others that I know. And while Arrowsmith didn't necessarily follow the path I would have chosen for him, he found what made him happy and fulfilled, despite the many missteps along the way.

I also loved all of the medical references. This book was written nearly 100 years ago, but many of the issues it presents are still relevant to medicine today. Do we overprotect in matters of public health? Are scientific discoveries of any worth if they can't be applied directly to health? Do we wait to prove those discoveries through properly controlled and randomized trials, or is it unethical to withhold a treatment we think might help? These are issues I think about on a daily basis, and although people who aren't involved in medical occupations and studies may not think about them as frequently, they certainly apply to all of us, especially in light of recent changes in litigation.

Another part of the novel that fascinated me was Arrowsmith's relationship with  Leora. Granted, I know that she is a detriment to feminism. Malleable and submissive and at times mistreated by Arrowsmith (generally through idiocy rather than genuine malice on his part), she certainly isn't a good role model or a strong woman. And their relationship wasn't perfect, either -- she supports him too much, while supports her too little. However, there was something about their love for each other, despite the differences and the foolish mistakes and the inequality, that was touching. They are so close to each other that at times they seem to blend together. This isn't a popular concept in our modern day and age -- we are all about asserting ourselves and having our own identities and preserving our sense of self no matter how many children we have or who we are in relationships with -- but to me, there is still something romantic about it. I think I believe that real love means a willingness to give everything to each other -- but hopefully, being with someone who respects you enough to keep you yourself. I am now getting off topic and waxing philosophical.

So, in brief, Arrowsmith is a fantastic and complex book. Whether or not you have a particular interest in the medical world, I think it has a lot of offer. The Pulitzers have yet to let me down.

4 stars

Warnings: I honestly can't remember. It's probably rated PG? I don't remember anything appallingly offensive, but there is probably something in there that would offend someone sensitive.

Unaccustomed Earth

Sunday, October 10, 2010


Yup, two reviews in one day. It's hard for me to blog during the week, so Sunday is my blogging catch-up day.

I LOVE Indian culture. I love the food (you should probably go get some takeout samosas right now and then finish reading), I love the movies (and then go rent Lagaan) and I LOVE the books. My grandma gave me Jhumpa Lahiri's first two books, Interpreter of Maladies and The Namesake, after discovering this fact, and I loved them both, so I was excited to find Jhumpa's (pronunced "joompa") third book waiting for me on the library shelf.

Unaccustomed Earth is a book of eight short stories. Five of them are unconnected, and the last three involve the same two characters. The title comes from Nathaniel Hawthorne's "The Custom-House:" (Read "The Custom House" here. I am going to once I finish writing this post - I can't remember what it was about - 11th grade seems like a long time ago).

Human nature will not flourish, any more than a potato, if it be planted and replanted, for too long a series of generation, in the same worn-out soil. My children have had other birthplaces, and so far as their fortunes may be in my control, shall strike their roots into unaccustomed earth."

This book (and honestly, Lahiri's other two books) are about the lives of immigrants from India to the United States - their experiences in "unaccustomed earth." They must learn to adjust, for better or for worse, to their new surroundings, and those adjustments are always rocky.

Lahiri's stories are not just about immigrants, however - they are about laying bare the unanticipated moments that manage to change the course of the rest of your life. Lahiri manages to catch the precise moments when things start to fall apart, particularly in relationships - "She clipped the ribbon with scissors and stuffed the whole thing into the garbage, surprised at how easily it fit, thinking of the husband who no longer trusted her, of the son whose cry now interrupted her, of the fledgling family that had cracked open that morning, as typical and as terrifying as any other" (173).

That is the end of one of the stories, by the way - cheerful, isn't it? Sometimes Lahiri is too sad and too real - some of the stories stopped at places so tragic it made me feel like I was watching a frightening scene, even though nothing truly horrifying was occurring, just the mistakes that are possible in our lives. She takes small moments and magnifies them for all their potential ramifications, which isn't always uplifting.

However, part of Jhumpa's skill is that even though sometimes I didn't like her story, I couldn't stop reading until I finished, even skipping ahead to skim random pages and scattered sentences and then going back to finish the story anyway. Her stories are compelling and believable. There is a reason this lady won the Pulitzer. Her characters are flawed but endearing. (My favorite part is when a man is told not to color his rapidly graying hair - "it was distinguished, women would be drawn do it. He hadn't believed her but she was right; every woman he'd ever been involved with had confessed, at one point or another, that they found his gray hair sexy" (101). As the wife of a twenty-something going gray, I couldn't agree more!)

All things considered, this is a good book. Jhumpa Lahiri is a phenomenal writer. I didn't always love it, and sometimes it left me in a somewhat depressed mood, but I am glad I read it and would recommend it with a grain of salt.* 3.5

*I always wondered what that phrase meant, so I looked it up for you in case you were wondering too.

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...