North and South by Elizabeth Gaskell

Monday, September 24, 2012

Title: North and South
Author: Elizabeth Gaskell
Genre: Classic
Published: 1855, originally (I read the public domain version on my Kindle)
Source: Personal copy
Read for: A Classics Challenge, Back to the Classics 2, The Classics Club

When Margaret's father feels inspired to change his life's path, they are forced to leave their beautiful home in the southern countryside of England and instead relocate to the northern mill town of Milton. The smoky air, crowded streets, and different personalities of the people disturb and frustrate Margaret and her family. However, as they spend more time in Milton, despite the difficulties and trials that befall their family, Margaret learns that northern England also has something to offer. Part of this transformation is the character of Mr. Thornton, a man who Margaret initially does not understand but grows to respect as she spends more time in Milton.

In some ways, North and South was reminiscent of Pride and Prejudice for me. Boy meets girl, girl scorns boy, boy does some kind, loving things for her family in order to win her affection. However, the backdrop is utterly different. The Hale family is dealing with a complete upheaval of their lifestyle, resulting in poor health and disastrous consequences for some of the characters. North and South does not only focus on the interactions between the characters, but also larger issues such as the justness of strikes in the Industrial Revolution and what is owed to both the manufacturers and the men and women who operate their factories. While at times, North and South felt a bit heavy to me, overall I felt it was an enlightening read that caused me to think about issues that wouldn't have crossed my mind otherwise.

One prevalent aspect of North and South that I enjoyed was the fact that nearly all the characters, at some point, performed an action that was either wrong or was construed as wrong by society. These characters were not black and white idealistic constructions. Mr. Hale leaves the Church after a lifetime of service. Margaret's brother, Frederick, is in exile from England after participating in a mutiny in the Navy. Margaret is caught in a lie. Moral dilemmas abound in North and South, and it was a powerful experience to read how the different characters resolved those dilemmas. Each character certainly had a conscience, but the way they resolved their dilemmas was not necessarily the most heavily traveled path.

I also enjoyed the romance, although the slow burn that lasted throughout most of the novel's pages wrapped up a little too quickly for me. Initially, Margaret and Mr. Thornton do not understand each other -- she thinks, as a manufacturer, he is low class, and he thinks she is entirely too prideful (maybe a reverse Pride and Prejudice, then). However, despite the initial exposure to each others' less desirable qualities (in the mindset of the day, of course -- I still have never quite been able to understand class differences as they existed in previous times) they both act in certain situations in a way to gain the respect and admiration of the other. However, countless misunderstandings prevent them from confessing how they feel until the very end of the book. I would have liked more than a few sentences of resolution, after so much waiting and anguishing.

Elizabeth Gaskell is clearly an accomplished writer. Her words conveyed her images powerfully to me. Her writing wasn't flowery or descriptive like many authors I appreciate, but she wrote poignantly and with conviction, and her words had a lot of strength. Even in the sections that were not quite as interesting to me, such as all the talk about the strike (it was good, but there was quite a bit of it), while I was at times impatient to move on with the story, I could still appreciate that the writing was excellent.

North and South is a well-written, well-constructed book -- it is clear why it is a classic, and I enjoyed how much it made me think. While I didn't really emotionally connect with it, I think North and South is a worthwhile read for anyone hoping to expand their British literary horizons beyond the standard classic fare of Jane Austen and Charles Dickens.

3.75 stars

Warnings: Some violence

14 comments:

  1. For me, this is a case of loving the miniseries more than the book...mostly because of how hot I think Richard Armitage is as Thornton and because I skip some of the "boring" social commentary and just stick to the romance. But I did enjoy the book when I read it; I just like the movie more.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I have heard lots of people raving about the miniseries, so I am really looking forward to watching it. I enjoyed the book, too, but expected a little more because of all the people I know of who love the story.

      Delete
  2. North and South was a combination read/listen for me, and I loved it. Hope to read more Gaskell soon.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I am hoping to read more as well. I have heard good things about Mary Barton (I think that is the title?) and am planning on reading that one for sure.

      Delete
  3. I can't remember if you've read Wives and Daughters but I highly recommend it if you haven't. I like this one and love the movie but W&D will always be my favorite!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I haven't read it -- good to know that Wives and Daughters is good! I am definitely looking forward to reading more Elizabeth Gaskell.

      Delete
  4. Okay . . . I seriously keep telling people this book is a lot like Pride and Prejudice, only set in industrial northern England, and everyone I tell that to always looks at me funny. I'm glad you saw the similarities too! And seriously, watch the mini-series. The lack of romantic resolution you were talking about in the book doesn't apply to the movie AT ALL. The final scene is probably one of the most perfect romantic scenes ever!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I really need to watch the mini-series soon. Hopefully it is still on Netflix. And I'd love to see a better final scene so I suppose I should set aside time now!

      Delete
  5. I'm dying to fit in a re-WATCH of this movie. I've read it twice already... wonder if I need a re-read too? :) Love it more and more each time. I do agree with Jenny though, Wives and Daughters may even be better...

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. This is making me excited both to watch North and South and to get into Wives and Daughters one of these days!

      Delete
  6. I'm a HUGE fan of the mini-series myself. So I'll agree with all the other people and say you must watch it as soon as possible! That said, I agree the resolution in the book felt very, very rushed. The mini-series does help tremendously with that. And I could also see the similarities to Pride and Prejudice, but I enjoyed all the other side stories that interconnected and kept me on the edge of my seat. Historical novels are so fascinating to me, learning about those eras of time.

    Okay, babblings are done. But DO watch any Elizabeth Gaskell adaptation, they all are wonderful! :)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I think I am going to watch it this week! I am taking nursing boards tomorrow and then after that will be home free. Hooray!

      Delete
  7. I am looking forward to reading this... as I haven't yet, nor have I seen the movie but have heard so much about it! -Sarah

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. It is a good book! It seems like a favorite for many people.

      Delete

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...